I, like the rest of you, are in the same boat. My
expectations were greater than what I have recieved so far. Although I
originally promised a review of the whole portal, I think that today, I am going
to kind of talk about, or highlight the good and the bad (in my opinion) or the
Battle Challenge Arena and its installation process. I could just complain, but
that would not do anyone any good. So the way I am going to do this is in
a table format which lists each step from the opening of the battle area to
actually battling someone. For each step, I will briefly state my experience
with it, what I expected, what I think 4Kids could do to make it better, then
finally, any hints I have if possible (I will later update it with more helpful
hints (from you guys), as I get more.
BATTLE CHALLENGE QA
|
|
ACTION/AREA STEPS |
MY
EXPERIENCE |
EXPECTATIONS |
SUGGESTIONS TO 4KIDS |
HINTS |
OPENING OF ARENA
|
There was to much waiting.
Although we had a late opening of the Portal on Wed., it was kind of
expected, but would have been nice to have been earlier. Kind of a
tease. |
I had expected the battle
area to open earlier in the day, or have a more definite time as to when
it would launch. |
Under promise and over
produce. If you say the 26th, say at 5:00 PST, then open it up at
4:00. |
Everyone needs to relax.
This is a new game with all kinds of functionality that has never before
been provided for a TCG. There will be and are some bumps, but
that is part of thie BETA launch. |
INITIAL LOGGING IN
|
Sometimes the login or
loading of the following screen may be slow |
Quicker loading of screens |
Fix load or software issues |
Brace yourself to wait a few
seconds |
INSTALLING CHAOTIC PAD
|
|
|
1. Finding the install |
At first I tried to set up my
army and then go to battle, but did not know that anything had to be
uploaded (as per 4Kids), but after going back to my forum, saw that
people were taling about something to upload. After a few more
minutes, I found the "ACTIVATION" button |
(1) I did not expect to have
to upload anything and (2) Since there was something to upload, I would
have expected it to be more pronounced or easier to find |
When clicking on the Battle
Challenge navigation icon for the first time, a BIG pop-up notice should
appear with specific instructions, or an email message, or even after
the first login into the Portal. Maybe the Activation button should be
blinking if your pad is not installed |
The "activation" button
appears on the top of the Welcome screen, right of the middle of the
screen (under ENTER THE CODE) |
|
2. Clicking on "Activation" |
Okay, brings you to a screen
that says instruction on next page |
Met |
N/A |
N/A |
|
3. Clicking on "Get Started" |
I come to a screen with a lot
of buttons to push/items to be installed on left of screen with stuff I
really cannot read or follow on right side |
I would have expected either
ONE button to push or detailed instructions |
Have detailed step-by-step
instructions on the entire installation procedure and/or create a
one-button package install where user clicks on one button, then either
follow the steps on the screen, just wait until the install is complete |
Click on the "Download
Complete Package," and just forget about the rest. |
|
4. Download Completion |
It just ended, with no notice |
A screen that said
"Installation Completed" with the next steps, or really something that
said - "you are ready to play". |
See expectations at left |
When the installation stops,
and there are no more "OK" or "Next" buttons to push, you need to then
install the pad. |
|
5. Installation of Pad |
I had to manually find, then
install the pad myself, but had to figure it out myself because the
"instruction" screen was not clear and the wording was extremely small. |
I would have expected, at
most, a button that said "download now" or best expectations was that
the install execution would have been part of the download process --
much better instructions |
Make it simpler for us, one
button, even one button with prompts is fine, but having to then find
the files is not cool. Also, better instructions on how to do this
would have been very, very helpful. |
After the files are
downloaded, you have to get the files from your start menu (bottom left
button), All Programs -> TC Digital -> Chaotic (mine does not say
Installer) |
|
6. Chaotic Patcher |
I did not see this coming |
I figured after selecting
that file, it would just install, or go to a promt screen (which I guess
it does after the Patcher) |
Rename the "Patcher" pop-up
so that users know what is happening, or at least have it say "Launch
screen will appear momentarily" |
You need to wait a few
seconds until the Launch screen appears. |
|
7. Launch Chaotic Pad |
Intersting to see that it
says that I will need to install this every time I play (at least it is
not a full download again) |
I guess I did expect to see a
prompt sreen. |
N/A |
Jusy click on the Launch
button |
|
8. Launc Pad Login |
Annoyed that I need to log in
a second time |
I am already logged in, why
do it again? |
Connect initial login with
launch, so that the first login is enough |
Login again |
|
9. Login Succesful |
Good to finally see a "sucessful"
screen. But bad instructions about accepting/making challenges,
especially if you do not have your decks set up |
Login Successful screen with
options as to where I may go from here: Build Decks, Challenge, etc. |
See left |
Click on "Minimize Game Pad."
You can go to the Battle Challenge, but make sure you have built proper
decks before going to battle |
|
ACTION/AREA STEPS |
MY
EXPERIENCE |
EXPECTATIONS |
SUGGESTIONS TO 4KIDS |
HINTS |
FREE DECKS
|
|
|
1. Finding Free Decks |
Unintentionally clicked on
the button for the free deck. I understood the instructions, however, if
I did not know about Chaotic, I would not have known which Deck belonged
to which tribe |
(1) Better notice on where to
find the free deck button, (2) The name of the tribe above/below each of
the decks |
Pop-up when entering Army
area for first time explaining about the free decks & where to find
them. A simple title to each of the decks would be helpful |
Choose the tribe (deck) that
you think will be of most benefit to you. Wait for email |
|
2. Free Deck Email |
Got the email, but the Logo
was not showing since I had my images off on AOL. My issue, not AO:s |
Met |
None |
The email should arrive in
only a few minutes - about 3 for me. |
|
3. Entering the Code |
Entered the codes easily with
no issues |
Met |
None |
Go to "ENTER THE CODE" at top
of page, enter the code given, then follow screen instructions |
|
ACTION/AREA STEPS |
MY
EXPERIENCE |
EXPECTATIONS |
SUGGESTIONS TO 4KIDS |
HINTS |
ARMY
|
Note: I had
already uploaded my cards and tried to create a Deck, but when I went to
battle, it said that I did not have 20 Attack cards. However, when I
went back to my deck, I could not add any Attack cards, so I am going to
go through the steps as though I was creating a new army. |
|
1. Creating a NEW Deck |
Seems easy enough to begin
with, but unsure as to where I should go |
Detailed instructions needed |
Create step-by-step
instructions on how to create an army |
Put in the name of the Deck
you are creating, then press "NEW" |
|
2. Add Attack Cards |
I am adding attack cards
first, because of prior tries where the Attack pad disappears.
While I see it, I am going to use it. |
Instruction on how, what
cards to add and Reminder of that 20 Attack cards are needed in a deck
to battle |
See left. Also some wa to
ensure that the pad does not disapear |
Drag and drop your attack
cards from your "Army" at the bottom into the pad that comes out from
the right side of the screen. Use Search Filter to "make it easier" |
|
3. Add Creature & Battle Gear |
First found it hard to find
all cards (too small on bottom and too much time to make the pictures
larger) |
Easier filter & way to see
the cards & stats |
Maybe a less graphically
intensive display of cards so that they load faster, or have basic stats
on mouseover. Also Search Filter is not always easy to use, sometimes it
will not "grab" the item I am trying to click on. |
I am not discussing tactics
here, but use the Search Filter to more easily find the cards you want
to use. |
|
4. Saving Deck |
I cannot find a way to save
what I had just created |
A "Save" button |
Create a save button, or let
us know that a save is not needed |
Just go somewhere else in the
Portal, it will save automatically |
|
5. Editing Deck |
Unable to change/edit the
Attack cards on the deck if I re-load the deck. The Attack oad
does not appear. |
I should be able to
edit/modify any deck as my base army or experience changes |
Allow us to edit a previously
created Army |
I guess you can change your
Creature and Battle gear for now, if you want. |
|
ACTION/AREA STEPS |
MY
EXPERIENCE |
EXPECTATIONS |
SUGGESTIONS TO 4KIDS |
HINTS |
BATTLING
|
At one point
when I clicked on "Coming Soon" icon on the top/middle of the page
(after my initial loading of the pad), my IE crashed and reloaded. I
then opened up the Portal again. Now when I try to challenge
someone, I get an "You Must Open Chaotic Game Before Challenging Another
Player" error. However, when I try to re-run the Launch Pad, I get
a message that reads "Please close all Chaotic Game instances and try
again. I then left the game and tried to log back in with no luck. I
then had to totally close and open up IE again. Then I was able to
come back in and load everything. |
|
1. The Challenge (Accepting) |
I went to the Battle
Challenge Area and saw who had challenges for me and clicked on one of
them. |
I guess, I did not expect to
go directly into the game so quick. I guess I will be expecting it
next time. |
No, it is something I will
just get used to. |
As soon as you accept/make a
challenge, get ready to battle right away. |
|
2. The Battle |
Very quick, for the first
time, it is hard to expect what is going to happen. |
I guess battles that are a
little slower, without the time limitations. |
Maybe an option to have
battles timed or not timed. |
Play the game offline a few
times to get used to how it is played, that way you are used to what all
of the different stats mean. You need to know your own cards as
well as your opponents. |
|
3. The Play |
Although I had the demo
decks, I never played with them, so althoug I knew the basics (from
reading & playing one demo), I basically threw out what I though
were my best attack cards without any real strategy. In a 1-on-1,
if you have the right cards, you are almost unbeatable. |
The game at this point, meets
my expectations. Although the play is a little quick, it is what I had
expected. Excellent. |
Keep up the good work, but
maybe slow the games down. |
Know your decks. Just like
any TCG, the more you play, the better you will get. |
|
4. Winning |
I am not gloating, but I won,
and it happendd so fast (probably beginners luck). I got a little
message as such, now I am trying to look for the statistic page too see
my win - have not been able to find it |
Easily find and view winning
statistics |
Need better indications,
instructions about where to find stats. |
Do you have any for me? |
I hope this helps you guys, or at
least gives you some comfort that your experiences may not be as different as
myself or other people out there. I guess overall, the Portal as a whole
(which I will be doing a full review on for a future blog), and the Battling are
cool, and I cannot wait for the multi-creature battles where there will be a lot
more strategy and skill involved. Kudos goes out to 4Kids for bring this
Portal to us (even with limited functionlaity), and I cannot wait for more.
*** Update: After writing the above,
I was poking around the forum and noticed that Dragonix created a detailed
walkthough that would take care of some of the mentioned issues above at
http://www.chaoticgame.com/Forum/Topic2590-5-1.aspx,
and it would be good to make sure that all users, especially new users know
about it. Thanks Dragonix!!!!